A freight sales commission plan should pay on gross profit, not revenue, and should treat commission as earned only when the customer has paid and the job's costs are final. Revenue moves with freight rates and pass-through charges; gross profit is the part of the invoice a salesperson actually influences. Most disputes come from a loose definition of commissionable gross profit, commission paid before the cash arrives, or no rule for leavers. This guide closes each gap and ends with a one-page example plan. Every rate here is illustrative, not market data.
Why commission is paid on gross profit, not revenue
Take one customer, one lane and USD 300 of profit per box. With the market at USD 4,000 a container, 5% of revenue pays USD 200, two thirds of the profit. When the rate falls to USD 2,000, the same plan pays USD 100 for identical work. A revenue plan also pays on duty and other disbursements, which carry no margin at all.
Revenue is not even a stable number. As our guide to gross versus net revenue recognition explains, the same job can be presented at full value or as a net fee depending on whether you act as principal or agent. Gross profit comes out the same either way.
Base plus commission, draw or agent-style pay
- Base plus commission. A salary carries the long build of a freight account and commission rewards results, usually above a threshold. It is the simplest structure to run.
- Draw against commission. An advance on future commission, useful while a new hire's pipeline builds. New York's Department of Labor says a draw is repayable only if the written agreement says so and states how often it is reconciled, and that a draw cannot be recouped from earnings other than commission.
- Agent-style pay. Commission only, with the person bearing their own costs. The label does not settle their status. GOV.UK tells employers to work out status in both employment law and tax law. California's test (Labor Code 2775) treats a worker as an employee unless the hirer proves three things, one being that the work is outside the usual course of its business, which is hard for someone selling the forwarder's own freight services, though exceptions exist. The Department of Labor proposed replacing its 2024 federal rule in February 2026, so check where that stands.
How to define commissionable gross profit
Start from job margin in the job file and write the definition line by line. The treatments below are conventions and choices, not rules. What matters is that the plan states them.
| Item | Usual treatment | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier, trucking, terminal costs | Deduct at actual invoiced cost | Paying on estimates pays on margin that may not exist |
| Duty, tax and other disbursements | Exclude both sides | Pass-through, no margin |
| Overseas agent profit share and fees | Deduct first | It was never your profit |
| Carrier rebates and volume incentives | Often kept at company level | Earned on the whole book and arrive late, so they rarely map to one job |
| Credit notes, claims, rate corrections | Deduct from the job | The profit did not exist |
| Bad debt | No separate deduction on a cash plan | Unpaid profit never became commissionable; deducting it again counts it twice |
| Overhead | Leave out | The salesperson cannot control it, and it turns a statement into an argument |
One control matters as much: nobody paid on gross profit should be able to edit job costs or accruals. Finance closes the job.
Pay on cash collected, and know what a clawback is
The common design is to pay on invoice and claw back if the customer does not pay. That is the wrong way round. If the plan says commission is earned only when the invoice is paid in full and the job is closed, nothing has to be clawed back for non-payment, because the commission never fell due. It also gives sales a stake in credit control and the payment terms they offer.
The distinction is legal too. New York's Department of Labor says earned commissions are wages, with deductions limited by statute, while unearned commissions can be adjusted under the written agreement. California's Labor Commissioner lists court decisions restricting offsets, including Hudgins v. Neiman Marcus (1995), on deductions for unidentified returns from commission sales. In Deleon v. Verizon Wireless (2012), a California appeal court upheld chargebacks because the plan stated that the payments were advances, not earned until a chargeback period ended. The definition of "earned" decides what you may recover.
Then state how partial payments are allocated, whether commission lapses on an invoice collected very late, and how late carrier invoices and credit notes are handled after payout: offset against future commission only, itemised, with a time limit.
New accounts, house accounts and tenure decay
Winning an account takes more selling than keeping it, so a common design pays a higher rate for a fixed period and then steps it down. That pushes the salesperson back towards new business. The risk is neglect of mature accounts, so keep a maintenance rate above zero or move them to an account manager.
Treat a "new account" as a customer with no shipment in 12 months, counting group companies as one. Treat accounts won by the owner, management-run tenders and routed freight controlled by an overseas agent as house accounts, at a low rate or none. Decide in the offer letter whether a book a new hire brings counts as new.
Shared accounts: operations, colleagues and overseas agents
- Two salespeople. Agree any split in writing before the first shipment, and name one manager who settles disputes.
- Operations. A salesperson's profit depends on people who earn no commission. A small team pool or service bonus recognises that. Use your KPIs and scorecards for what commission does not measure, such as quote-to-book conversion, claims and days sales outstanding.
- Overseas agents. Commission applies to your share only. On a job with USD 800 of profit split 50/50, which is a common convention rather than a rule, USD 400 is commissionable. Agents settle periodically, so treat a job as final only once its agent statement is reconciled.
Minimum margin floors for quoting
Set floors in money per job or per unit, not as a percentage alone: 10% of a USD 400 shipment is USD 40, and a percentage floor falls with the market. Build the figure from your per-shipment overhead, as in our guide to pricing a freight quote. A job below the floor can still ship, but it earns no commission unless a manager logs an exception. Test the floor against final margin, not the quoted one.
When a salesperson leaves with accounts
Prepare before anyone resigns: a notice period, a handover list and a named second contact on every major account, so the relationship does not live in one phone.
Write the commission run-off into the plan. One approach is to pay on jobs shipped before the leaving date as the cash arrives, for a fixed window. New York's guidance says earned commission must be paid after employment ends, and that unearned commission follows the agreement, which must cover the situation. GOV.UK says people are normally entitled to everything earned up to the day they finish. A clause forfeiting all unpaid commission on departure is the one to have a lawyer read first.
Non-solicit and non-compete clauses depend on jurisdiction. In the UK, the government's paper states that a non-compete, like any restraint of trade, is unenforceable unless the employer shows it is reasonable. That paper, which closed on 18 February 2026, also asked about non-dealing clauses; GOV.UK showed no outcome as of November 2026. In the US, the FTC's non-compete rule was blocked in court and the FTC dropped its appeals in September 2025, so enforceability is mainly a state-law question. California's Business and Professions Code 16600 voids employment non-competes "no matter how narrowly tailored", so take advice before relying on a customer non-solicit there.
Employment law points to check first
- Great Britain. Commission is wages under section 27 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. Section 13 allows a deduction only under statute, a contract term given or notified in writing beforehand, or prior written consent. The section 1 written statement, due by the first day, must give the method of calculating pay. GOV.UK says the "normal" rate of pay includes commission and that regular-hours workers get at least four weeks of leave at it, so holiday pay needs commission averaged in (Working Time Regulations, regulation 16).
- US federal. Under 29 CFR 778.117 commission on any formula goes into the regular rate for overtime. Under 778.119, a commission paid late is apportioned back over the weeks it was earned, with extra overtime paid: a real cost on a cash-collected plan with non-exempt staff. The outside sales exemption (29 CFR 541.500) needs the person customarily away from your premises, so a desk-based seller does not meet that test.
- California. Labor Code 2751 requires a written contract stating how commissions are computed and paid, a signed copy for the employee and a signed receipt. Its exclusion for bonus and profit-sharing plans does not cover an offer of a fixed percentage of sales or profits, so do not assume a gross-profit plan falls outside it.
- New York. The Department of Labor says the agreement must be written and signed by both sides. Other states differ.
A one-page example plan (illustrative numbers)
- Base: salary per contract.
- Commissionable gross profit: job revenue less actual direct costs, agent shares, credit notes and disbursements. Rebates and overhead excluded.
- Earned: when the invoice is paid in full and finance has closed the job.
- Threshold: the first USD 4,000 of monthly gross profit earns nothing, taken from the lowest-rate band first.
- Rates: 20% in an account's first 12 months, 10% in months 13 to 24, 5% after that and on house accounts.
- Floor: jobs under USD 150 earn nothing without a logged manager exception.
- Adjustments: credit notes and late costs offset future commission, itemised, for up to 12 months.
- Leaving: jobs shipped before the leaving date are paid as cash arrives, for six months.
Worked month: cash collected on closed jobs is USD 9,000 of profit on first-year accounts, USD 6,000 on second-year accounts and USD 5,000 on house accounts. The threshold removes USD 4,000 from the house band, leaving USD 1,000. Commission is USD 1,800 + USD 600 + USD 50 = USD 2,450. A USD 1,200 credit note on a first-year job paid last month takes off USD 240, so the statement pays USD 2,210.
What to do next
- Rerun last quarter's commission under the new definition and see who gains and loses.
- Define "earned" and have an employment lawyer in each country read it.
- Lock job costs against sales edits and publish the margin floor.
- Issue a monthly statement showing each adjustment.
More than 29,300 logistics companies are searchable by country and service in the CargoLinked directory, and the public requests board lists freight that shippers have posted for forwarders to quote on directly.
This is general information, not legal, tax, employment or financial advice. Employment law varies by country and state and changes; confirm the current rules with the relevant authority or a licensed professional before issuing a plan.



